Rubble and ruin

How Delhi homes were turned to rubble before the G20

frame
frame

When residents of a slum cluster in New Delhi's Janta Camp area heard that the G20 Summit was to be held in the Indian capital, barely 500 metres from their homes, they expected it would benefit them as well.

Instead, they were rendered homeless.

Dharmender Kumar, Khushboo Devi, and their three children were among scores of people across Delhi whose homes were demolished over the past few months - action that both residents and activists say is part of the beautification work for the summit on Sept. 9-10 summit.

Some of those living in the slum approached the Delhi High court to stop the evictions but the court ruled the settlements illegal. Then city authorities ordered them to vacate by May 31.

Officials of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s federal government, responsible for the demolitions, say the houses were built illegally on government land and their removal was “a continuous activity".

Homes in slums like the one in Janta Camp are built over years like patchwork. Most of the residents work nearby and have lived for decades within the confines of their small homes.

Add a description of the graphic for screen readers. This is invisible on the page.

The demolitions started four months ago. Bulldozers rolled in on a hot May morning, with video images of the demolition showing temporary homes made of tin sheet being razed, as former residents stand watching, some of them in tears.

Image depicting an Indian couple engaged in domestic chores, surrounded by various utensils.
Dharmender Kumar, shows a video to his wife Khushboo Devi as she prepares a meal inside their house, May 26, 2023. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi

The camp near Pragati Maidan, the summit’s main venue, is emblematic of much of the landscape in Delhi, as many of the city's 20 million people live in largely unplanned districts that have mushroomed over the years.

In 2021, housing minister Hardeep Singh Puritold parliament that 13.5 million people lived in the city’s unauthorized colonies in Delhi.

Add a description of the graphic for screen readers. This is invisible on the page.

"The government is demolishing houses and removing vulnerable people in the name of beautification without any concern about what will happen to them," said Sunil Kumar Aledia, executive director and founding member of the New-Delhi based Centre for Holistic Development, which works with the homeless.

"If this had to be done, residents should have been warned in time and places found where they could have been rehabilitated," he added.

The slum sits just off the main road near Pragati Maidan.

A map showing the Upper West side in New York City.

The entire slum area is canvassed by trees.

The same map now highlights 98th Street.

On May 31, 2023, officials and demolition crew demolished the entire area.

The same map now highlights three locations near 98th Street where something particulary important happened.

Last month, the Supreme Court ruled that squatters have no right to occupy public land, and can at best, seek time to vacate it and apply for rehabilitation.

At least 49 demolition drives in New Delhi between April 1 and July 27 led to nearly 230 acres (93 hectares) of government land being reclaimed, the junior housing minister, Kaushal Kishore, told parliament in July.

Image depicting a Hindu holyman talking to a man outside a slum.
Image depicting a pariah dog sleeping on pavement road next to a demolished slum.

LeftTopA Sadhu or a Hindu holyman talks to a man as they sit on a pavement outside a slum before its demolition, May 29, 2023. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi

RightBottomA dog sleeps on a pavement next to the remains of a slum after it was demolished by the authorities during the demolition drive, June 15, 2023. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi

"No house has been demolished to beautify the city for the G20 summit," he said.

The demolition of the Janta Camp shanties was a rude shock for Mohammed Shameem, another resident, who said he thought the "big people" attending the G20 summit would "give something to the poor".

He said, "The opposite is happening here. Big people will come, sit on our graves and eat”.

Image depicting a woman salvaging useful items from rubble.
Three women inspecting the razed slums with a crane in the center.
Image depicting a distressed man in tears while speaking on a mobile phone beside a pile of rubble.
Image depicting many security personnels standing on the road with a crane nearby.

Top LeftFirstKhushboo Devi collects the usable items from the rubble of her house during a demolition drive by the authorities at a slum area, June 1, 2023. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi

Top RightSecondWomen watch as an excavator demolished their houses during a demolition drive by the authorities at a slum area, June 1, 2023. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi

Bottom LeftThirdDharmender Kumar cries while talking on a phone after his house was demolished during a demolition drive by the authorities at a slum area near the upcoming summit venue in New Delhi, India, June 1, 2023. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi

Bottom RightFourthSecurity personnel stand guard during a demolition drive by the authorities, June 1, 2023. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi

For Kumar, who works as a clerk in a Pragati Maidan office, the demolition of his home and his family's eviction spells larger implications.

"If we relocate from here, my children's education will also suffer," he said. "Here they are able to study because the school is nearby." Two of Kumar's children - five-year-old Srishti and 10-year-old Eshant - go to a government school nearby. His younger daughter, Anokhee, is nine months old.

frame
Ishant Kumar, 10, and Srishti Devi, 5, children of Dharmender Kumar, watch their house being demolished, June 1, 2023. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi
frame
Ishant Kumar, 10, and Srishti Devi, 5, children of Dharmender Kumar, watch their house being demolished, June 1, 2023. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi

The family, which also includes Khushboo Devi's father, had lived in their shanty for 13 years until being told to vacate as "the area had to be cleaned".

"If they have to clean, that does not mean they will remove the poor,” Devi told Reuters.

“If the poor are looking so bad, they can make something nice, put a curtain or a sheet so that the poor are not visible.”

Image depicting a boy playing with a girl child inside a small room.
Image depicting a boy studying inside a small slum.

LeftTopDharmender Kumar and his wife Khushboo Devi load their belongings in a vehicle after their house was demolished during a demolition drive, India, June 1, 2023. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi

RightBottomDharmendra Kumar, his wife Khusboo Devi and their children sit inside their newly rented one-room house, July 1, 2023. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi

As the bulldozers left after reducing their homes to rubble, Kumar and his wife began gathering up belongings strewn by the road.

Afterwards, they piled these into a three-wheeler that took them to their new accommodation - a single room located 10 km (6.21 miles)away, for which they paid a monthly rent of 2,500 rupees ($30.21).

frame
Khushboo Devi rides an auto rickshaw with her children after their house was demolished, June 1, 2023. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi
frame
Khushboo Devi rides an auto rickshaw with her children after their house was demolished, June 1, 2023. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi

Their daughter carefully lifted a peach-coloured dress that had been thrown to the ground, along with everything else that her parents owned, and dusted it off.

Two months later, in August, the family returned to a part of the Janta Camp area that had escaped the bulldozers, paying a higher rent of 3,500 rupees for a room.

"It was difficult for my children to go to school everyday from the place we were staying in earlier,” Kumar said. “I want them to study and do well, we returned for their sake," Kumar said.

Edited by

Anand Katakam, Simon Scarr and Raju Gopalakrishnan