SA MEDICAL JOURNAL 13 FEBRUARY 1982
227
Hypoplasia or absence of the depressor
anguli oris muscle and congenital
abnormalities, with special reference to
the cardiofacial syndrome
S. E. LEVIN,
N. H. SILVERMAN,
S. MILNER
Summary
An asymmetrical crying facies due to hypoplasia or
absence of the depressor anguli oris muscle
(DAOM) was observed in 23 infants and children.
The cases were divided into two groups. Group 1
consisted of 12 patients who had associated cardiac
abnormalities. In group 2 were 11 patients' who
either had other non-cardiac abnormalities (6) or no
other abnormalities (5).
The associated cardiac anomalies recorded in the
literature are reviewed and 2 infants in this series are
reported with abnormalities not previously
described. The results of chromosomal analysis
have generally been found to be normal, although a
patient in our series was found to have trisomy E
(18). The incidence of hypoplasia of the DAOM in
newborn infants in a maternity hospital is assessed
and was found to be lower than reported in other
studies.
It is concluded that a detailed aM careful
examination for congenital abnormalities should be
carried out on every child with an asymmetrical
crying facies.
In rhis paper we report on 23 cases of congenital weakness of
the DAOM encountered ar a children's hospital and a maternity
hospital. The incidence of this syndrome among newborn infants
at the maternity hospital has been estimated. A case associated
wirh a chromosomal abnormality - trisomy 18, not previously
described - will be presented in some detail, and all the cardiac
anomalies associated with DAOM weakness will be reviewed,
including 2 previously unreported cardiac abnormalities
observed in our series.
Patients and methods
Of 23 infants with weakness of the DAOM, 18 were observed at
rhe Transvaal Memorial Hospiral for Children and 5 at its
newborn service at the Queen ViclOria Maternity Hospiral.
S. Afr. med. J., 61, 227 (1982).
Isolared unilareral partial facial paralysis involving rhe mentalis,
quadratus labii inferioris and depressor anguli oris muscles had
previously been observed in young children,I,2 bur ir was nor
until 1966 rhar Cayler J noted the association of this facial
abnormality with congenital heart disease. He extended his
series over the year lO include 30 cases of the cardiofacial
syndrome.4-6 In addition, there were 2 children with facial
weakness and heart murmurs not caused by congenital heart
disease. Cayler's observations have been confirmed by other
workers in the USA,? France,9 the UK,lO,11 Canada 12 and
Rhodesia. l ]
Recent studies have stressed thar the asymmetrical crying
facies caused by congenital hypoplasia or absence of the
depressor anguli oris muscle (DAOM) may occur as an isolated
anomaly or may be associated with abnormalities involving
systems other than the cardiovascular system,12,14-16
Department of Paediatrics, Johannesburg Hospital and
University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg
S. E. LEVIN, M.B. B.CH., D.C.H. (R.c.P. & S.), f.R.C.P.(EDIN.)
N. H. SIL VERMAN, M.B. B.CH., F.C.P. (S.A.) (present address:
University of California, San Francisco, California, 94143 USA)
S. MILNER, M.B. B.CH., F.C.P. (SA)
Date received: 15 May 1981.
Fig, 1. Asymmetrical crying facies. There is weakness of the DAOM on the
right side.
228
SA MEDIESE TYDSKRIF 13 FEBRUARIE 1982
Aparr from a detailed history and physical examination, \\'here
indicated, roentgenographic and electrocardiographic rudie
were carried our. Further special im'estigations included cardiac
catheterization in 4 cases, chromo ome analysis in 3,
electromyography in 2 and detailed \'iral rudies in 2. Autopsies
were carried out on all 5 children in the series who died.
During a 2-year period at the maternity hospital there were
8845 deliveries, and particular attention was paid to the presence
or absence of an asymmetrical crying facies as part of the routine
physical examination of newborn infants between the 4th and
6th days after birth.
The cases \\'ere divided into t\\·o group. Infants with an
as ociated cardiac abnormality \\'ere placed in group I and tho e
with no ob en'ed congenital cardiac abnormality in group 2.
Patient
No.
Sex
F
Results
Group 1 (Table I)
There \\'ere 12 children in this group (5 males and 7 females),
of ages ranging from I day to 2 Fars and 11 months. Weakness of
the DAOM was observed on the left side in half the cases (Fig. 1).
The cardiac abnormalities were confirmed at open-heart
surgery or autopsy in 8 of the 12 patients. In addition to the
cardiac anomalies, 9 of the 12 patients had abnormalities
invoh'ing other system, e.g. keletal, respiratory and gastrointestinal. Patients 6 and 7 had cardiac abnormalities not
pre\'iously described in association \\'ith \\'eakne~ of the
DA01\L
TABLE I. DAOM WEAKNESS AND CARDIAC ABNORMALITIES
Side of
Special investigations
Cardiac
DAOM
Birth
Age first
abnormalities
or procedures
weight (g)
weakness
seen
ASD (secundum)
Right
Cardiac catheterization,
2585
2 yrs 9 moo
and left SVC
open-heart surgery
VSD (clinical)
VSD (clinical)
2
3
M
F
2443
2563
1 yr 4 moo
3d
Right
Left
4
M
2841
1d
Left
Cardiac catheterization,
viral studies
(negative), autopsy
TGA and VSD
5
F
3068
6 wks
Left
6
F
2060
1d
Left
Chromosomal analysis
(46 XX)
Autopsy
Tricuspid atresia
and PDA
Dextrocardia
(no intrinsic heart
abnormality)
7
M
NK
2d
Left
Surgery, autopsy
8
F
2840
3d
Right
Cardiac catheterization,
autopsy (age 8 ' / 2 mo.)
Isolated origin of
left subclavian
artery off left
pulmonary artery,
right-sided aortic
arch and PDA
Truncus arteriosus
9
M
3750
8 moo
Right
10
M
2443
6 1/ 2 wks
Left
Electromyography
of facial muscles,
chromosomal analysis
(46 XV)
Chromosomal analysis
(trisomy E (18»,
viral studies (negative),
autopsy
VSD,
nodular thickening
of pulmonary and
aortic valves
11
F
2898
2 yrs 11 moo
Right
Cardiac catheterization,
open-heart surgery
ASD,
PDA
12
F
3494
6d
Right
Cardiac catheterization,
open-heart surgery
Pulmonary atresia,
VSD,
PDA
Probable truncus
arteriosus
Other
abnormalities
Right ear lobe
attached to neck,
slight hypoplasia of
right side of
mandible,
trigger finger 5th left
None
Infant of diabetic
mother
Anal atresia,
ex omphalos, absent
right radius and
thumb
Cleft palate,
absent ears
Sacral myelomeningocele, hypoplastic
right lung, single
umbilical artery
Tracheooesophageal
fistula
Right mentalis
muscle smaller than
left (on dissection)
Absent right radius,
hemivertebrae,
anal stenosis
Horseshoe kidney,
single umbilical
artery, undescended testes,
partial eventration
of right diaphragm
Absent right kidney,
small right femoral
epiphysis
Azygous lobe of
right lung
NK = not known: ASD = atrial septal defect; SVC = superior vena cava; TGA - transpositIon of the great arteries: PDA - patent ductus arteriosus:
VSD = venlrlcular septal defect
SA MEDICAL JOURNAL 13 FEBRUARY 1982
Case 6. A female infant with a birth weight of 2 050 g had a
sacral myelomeningocele, weaknes of the DAOM on the left
and a single umbilical artery. In addition the heart was situated
in the right chest and there were audible systolic and diastolic
murmurs. Roentgenograms of the abdomen revealed situs
solitus. Death occurred I month later, and autopsy revealed
dextroversion of the heart with a hypoplastic right lung. There
were no intracardiac abnormalities. It was assumed that the
cardiac murmurs were functional in origin and produced by
blood flow through a distorted heart.
Case 7. A male infant was diagnosed as having a tracheooesophageal fistula at 2 days· of age. In addition, weakness of the
DAOM on the left side of the face was noted. He underwent
surgery for the oesophageal atresia and died at the age of 6 days
after a stormy postoperative course. Autopsy re\·ealed isolated
origin of the subclavian artery from the left pulmonary artery
(Fig. 2). A right-sided aortic arch was also present.
229
group. One 4-month-old child with a \·iral illness was uspected
to have myocarditi . As ociated non-cardiac abnormalities,
major and minor, were found in the remaining 5 patients.
Chromosomal analysis
Normal karyotypes were found in patients 5 and 9 (group 1),
while trisomy 18, suspected on clinical examination, was
confirmed in patient 10 of group I (see case report belo\\·).
Case report. A male infant weighing only 2443 g was
delivered 2 weeks after the expected date. He was the 8th child
born to a 39-year-old mother and 44-year-old father. No serious
illness had occurred during the pregnancy. Cyanosis was noted
hortly after birth and he wa transferred from an outlying
hospital at the age of 25 days. His weight \\·as 2500 g, length 44
cm and skull circumference 37,2 cm. A number of abnormalitie
suggested trisomy 18; there was micrognathia, a highlv arched
palate and low-slung ears, the left being adherent to the side of
the skull and the right a 'bat ear'. Weakness of the DAOM on the
left was seen on crying. There was moderate webbing of the neck
with a 10\\· hairline. There were single palmar creases in both
hands with fixed flexion deformities of the 2nd, 3rd, 4th and 5th
fingers. 'Rockerbottom' feet were also present. The kull was
dolichocephalic with a very large patent anterior fontanelle.
Examination of the cardiO\·ascular system re\·ealed cardiomegaly
with biventricular hypertrophy. A pansystolic murmur was
audible at the 4th left interspace with a gallop sound at the apex.
The respiratory rate was mildly increased at 52/min and the li\·er
was palpable 2 cm below the right costal margin. Other
abnormalities were a left inguinal hernia with undescended
testes, a prominent coccyx, limited abduction of the hips, a
convergent squint and some hypertonia. Serological tests for
toxoplasmosis and rubella were negative. Chromosomal analysis
confirmed tri omy 18. The infant developed increasing cyanosis
with apnoeic spells and died when 44 days old. The principal
findings at autopsy were: single umbilical artery, horseshoe
kidney, mild eventration of right diaphragm, and a central liver
with ~ loose mesentery. Cardiac abnormalities included a large
ventricular septal defect (VSD) with nodules on the pulmonary
and aortic \·alyes. The foramen O\·ale was patent and the lungs
were atelectatic.
Electromyography
Fig. 2. Front view of the heart with left subclavian artery originating from
the left pulmonary artery (curved arrow). The right-sided aortic arch is also
demonstrated (straight arrow).
Group 2 (Table II)
There were II children in this group (6 males and 5 females), .
of ages ranging from I day to 16 mqnths. Involvement of the
DAOM was observed on the left side in 6 cases and on the right
in 5.
No congenital abnormalities were detected in 6 of the II
infants. Patient 4 was examined only once, at the age of 4 days,
after which she was lost to follow-up; although an associated
cardiac abnormality might have become evident later, in the
absence of further information the patient has been placed in this
This was performed in 2 patients - patient 9 in group I and
patient 8 in group 2. In patient 9 (group I) the electromyogram
(EMG) of the right lower lip showed no evidence of denervation.
On movement a low-amplitude (100 - 150 !J. V) pattern was seen
and interference. was markedly reduced. Individual motor unit
potentials, however, were quite normal in appearance. The
EMG ofthe right frontalis and left lower lip showed a normal full
interference pattern with the amplitude much greater (350 !J. V).
An attempt to stimulate the facial nerve was not successful.
In patient 8 (group 2) the EMG showed no denervation or excess irritability of muscles to the left lower lip. On volitional
movement there was a mildly reduced pattern with a maximal
amplitude of 600 !J. V. The individual potentials were of normal
configuration. The right lower lip showed a good and full
interference pattern \\·ith maximal amplitude of 800 !J. V. The
amplitude of evoked potentials on stimulating the seventh nen·e
on the left was therefore much smaller than on the right. Nen·e
conduction on both left and right sides was normal and
comparable.
Incidence of weakness of DAOM
During the 2-year period during which particular attention
was paid to an asymmetrical crying facies at the Queen Victoria
230
SA MEDIESE TYDSKRIF 13 FEBRUARIE 1982
TABLE 11. DAOM WEAKNESS WITH OR WITHOUT NON-CARDIAC ABNORMALITIES
Patient
No.
Side of
DAOM
Special investigations
weakness
or procedures
Sex
Birth
weight (g)
Age
first seen
F
NK
16 moo
Left
2
3
F
M
3608
3000
15 moo
3 moo
Left
Left
4
5
F
M
2950
3239
4d
1 d
Left
Right
6
F
3523
12 d
Right
7
M
3300
4 moo
Right
8
M
3068
9 moo
Left
9
F
NK
4 moo
Left
10
M
3310
9 moo
Right
11
M
2670
4d
Right
K
nOt
nown; IVP --=- Intravenous pyelography. CPK
Other abnormalities
Remarks
Left lower lobe
pneumonia
Pyrexial convulsion
Radiographs, ECG normal
Posterior encephalocele (resected),
rudimentary right
ear
Right facial
weakness pr~sent at
8 moo
DAOM weakness
still present at
13 moo
Electromyography,
viral studies (negative),
IVP, radiographs and
ECG - normal
Radiographs, ECG normal, raised serum CPK
Radiographs,
ECG - normal
Single umbilical artery,
congenital urethral valves,
sacral sinus, fusion
CS and C6 vertebrae
Hypospadias,
Mother on antimental retardation,
epileptic therapy
spastic
throughout
quadriparesis
pregnancy
? Myocarditis,
viral infection
Hypoplasia of toes
Re-examination at
19 mo., DAOM
and right foot
weakness still
present
Right ear hypoplastic
creatinine phosphokinase
Marerniry Hospiral, rhere were 8845 deliveries and 5 babies had
weakness of rhe DAOM. This represenrs an incidence of 0,57 per
1000 live binhs.
Discussion
This series again confirms rhar while unilareral weakness of rhe
DAOM may occur as an isolared finding ir is more ofren
associared wirh one or more congeniral abnormaliries.
Cardiac lesions in association with hypoplasia
ofDAOM
Table II I documenrs rhe cardiac abnormaljries in 85 reponed
examples of rhe cardiofacial syndrome (including our 12 cases).
A large variery of lesions has been described. Howel'er, 40 ofrhe
85 ca es are accounred for by rhe diagnosric caregories ofVSD,
rerralogy of Fallor or pulmonary arresia wirh VSD, and parenr
ducrus aneriosus. In our serie 2 anomalies nor previously
described hal'e been encounrered - dexrroversion II'irh
funcrional sysrolic and diasrolic murmurs and i olared origin of
rhe lefr subclavian anery from rhe lefr pulmonary anery."
Mosr of rhe reponed cases (including our oll'n) hal'e been seen
from a highly selecred popularion. Perlman and Reisner" were
rhe firsr II'orkers who artempred a pro pecril'e assessmenr of rhe
prel'alence of rhe asymmerrical crying facies among 6360
newborn infanrs. They found 41 examples, giving an incidence
of 1 in 155. Similarly, Papadaros eT al. I I> found an incidence of
TABLE Ill. CARDIAC LESIONS DESCRIBED IN
ASSOCIATION WITH DAOM HYPOPLASIA
(85 CASES)
Lesion
VSD ,",9,111""
No. cases
20
Tetralogy of Fallot 6 !"
PA + VSD'
PDA",l1
10
1
9
Coarctation of aorta (± other
lesions, e.g. VSD, PDA)o.1J.J4
ASD's
ASD and other lesions (e.g. VSD,
PS or AI, PDAr"
PS'"> 6
Hypoplastic RV syndrome,,,·6.11
TA'~!!
A-V canal""
TGA,,,·9
6
4
3
4
5
4
4
3
11
Single ventricle complex o.l1
Other cardiac anomalies,"·7.11
2
10t
. Our senes.
1: total anomalous
pulmonary venous drainage - 1; aortic stenosis - 1: myocarditis - 1: POAbicuspid aortic valve - double aortic arch - 1: left subclavian artery arising from
left pulmonary artery 1; dextrocardia (dextroversion) 1; arrhythmia
(paroxysmal atrial tachycardia) - 1.
PA
pulmonary atresia: PDA
patent ductus arteriosus: ASD :;;: atrial septal
defect: PS .:=.. pulmonary stenosIs: AI = aortiC Incompetence: RV ::;::- right ventricle:
TA
truncus artertosus: A-V::;::- atrioventricular: TGA :;;: transposition of the great
arteries.
+ InnomInate artery compression - 2 cases. mitral atresia -
=
=
SA MEDICAL JOURNAL 13 FEBRUARY 1982
0,82% among 4530 consecuti\'e births, and in a later study by
Alexiou er (/1. 18 the figure wa 0,68%. Wle examined 8845 live
neonates O\'er a 2-year period and were able to find only 5 \\'ith
unilateral DAOM weakness. The reason for this striking
difference is not known. In a much earlier study'Y it was claimed
that in most cases facial paresis in the newborn infant is
associated with intrapartum pressure on the exposed portion of
the facial nen·e. Hepner lY found that 34 of 46 infants had leftsided paresis; all had been in the left occipito-anterior or left
transverse positions during deli\·ery. Similarly, Israeli \\"Orkers ' ;
al 0 found the incidence to be highest on the left side. It therefore
seems likely that obstetric factor played a part in these cases. On
the other hand, in the series reported by Papadatos er al. 16 28 of
37 neonate had left-sided weakness and yet obstetric
complications appeared to ha\'e been largely ruled out. It \\'ould
appear that further studies on newborn populations combined
with long-term follow-up are indicated. Furthermore, Alexiou
er al. 18 found that 20% of infants with DAOM hypoplasia had
congenital malformations while the figure for a control neonatal
population was 2,7%.18
In this series 10 patients had an associated unilateral anomaly;
this was on the ame side a the weak DAOM in 8 case. Thi
observation is in accord with that of Pape and Pickering,12 who
first drew attention to this association. Of the 6 patients with no
other detectable abnormalities, 5 had asymmetrical crying facies
on the left. Thi left-sided predominance was comme'nted on b\'
Perlman and Reisner,l; and \\'as also found in the 2 reports from
Greece .16.18
While there should not be much clinical difficulty in
differentiating weakness of the DAOM from a true facial
paralysis, !.i·1 any doubt can be dispelled by electromyography.
With facial nerve palsy there is elevated excitability of the facial
nerve with diminished voluntary unit activity, fibrillations and
sharp \\'aves at rest. In contrast, infants with an affected DAOM
ha\'e clear-cut nen'e latency of normal duration, \\'hile the EMG
generall\' shows diminished motor unit acti\·ity. This \\'as found
in a paediatric neurological clinic by Nelson and Eng ll in 7
patients \\'ith no other abnormalities. No EMGs were carried out
in Pape and Pickering's large series. 12 On re\'ie\\' of the literature
20 more patients \\'ith weakness of the DAO,\19.1O.lli.I".:1O ha\'e
undergone electromyography or electrical studies, \\'ith findings
similar ro those described above. To this may be added 2 of our
patients who have shown normal nerve conduction \\'ith
electromyographic features typical of a weak DAOM, thus
making a total of 29 cases in which this study has been found to
be positi\·e. Recently Mo nreaP 1has questioned the reliability of
the EMG, because of technical difficulties in obtaining records.
However, it is difficult ro refute the finding of 6 different
im'estigarors, all of whom describe an identical EMG pattern,
\\'hen present, in association w'ith DAOM \\·eakness.
MonreaPI also reported 5 patients \\'ith this syndrome (of a
total· of 13) who displayed additional peri-oral anomalies on the
supposedly normal or strong side. He questioned the 'sidedness'
of the anomaly and postulated that the side of the lip that pulls
lowest is the abnormal one. This fails to explain the lack of
depression of the angle of the mouth by the DAOM on the other
('normal') side with crying. In the discussion MonreaPI admits
that 'we cannot ignore the previous work gathered by others and
View publication stats
231
admit that the hypoplasia of the DAOJ\l may exist in some cases'.
In search of aetiological facrors chromo ome studies ha\'e been
carried out on a rotal of 20 children with \\'eakness of the DAO,\l
and congenital anomalies.'-'·9 II No consistent or significant
abnormalities were found. To this may be added 2 of our patients
who were found to have normal karyotypes. However, we
observed an asymmetrical crying facies in a child with trisom\'
18. This appears ro be the first documented instance linking the
findings bf weakness of the DAOM and a chromosomal
abnormality. Further re\'iew of the literature regarding trisomy
1 revealed comments1~ ~ 1 that facial as\'mmetry or facial palsy
has been obsen'ed in less than 10% of such patient . Exact figures
do not appear to be a\'ailable (P. E. Polani - personal
communication), and furthermore the nature of the facial
weakness has not been delineated. There is a report 2; of an infant
with Edward's syndrome and congenital facial palsy of the lower
motor neuron type (invoh'ement of the frontalis, le\'ator
palpebrae superioris and lower facial muscles). The author
suggested a congenital agenesis of the seventh nerve nucleus. On
the other hand, Smith er al. 26 drew attention to the fairly
frequent finding of hypoplasia or aplasia of skeletal muscles. The
finding of unilateral weakness of the DAOM in our patient with
trisomy 18 may be another example in this context.
A recent report documents e\'idence for hereditary factors in
the aetiology of this muscle anomal y.16 In a series of 37 neonate .
\\'ith hypoplasia of the DAOM, there \\'ere 17 first- or econddegree relati\'es with 10\\'er lip asymmetry. J::urther example of a
familial incidence have been published.~u,
Our study affords further evidence that weakness of the
DAOM may occur as an isolated abnormality or may be
associated with other anomalies, in particular cardiO\'ascular and
skeletal. We support the contention that the finding of an
asymmetrical crying facies should be regarded in the same light
as that of a single umbilical artery. If present, a careful search
should be carried out for other congenital abnormalities. 11.1'
REFERE"CES
1. Hoefnagel, D. and Penr\',]. K. 19601: "ew' Engl. ] ..\led .. 262, 1126.
2..\\arina. H. 11953,: Surg. Gmec Ob>let., 96. 433.
3. Cader, G. G. 11967): fled iatric" -to, 666.
4. Idem (1968):]. Pediat., 73, 953.
5. Idem (1969): Arch. Dis. Childh., 44,69.
6. Cadcr, G. G., Blumenfcld, C. .\\. and Andc"an, R. L. (1971): Che>l, 60, 161.
7. Strong, \\'. B. and Silben, D. R. (1969): Amcr. Heart j., 78, 279.
8. "lad\', G. and Falger, G..\\. (1973): Amcr. j. Di,. Child .• 126,120.
9. Vergcr, P., Guillard,] ..\\., Sandler, B. cl ,iI. (1970): Rc\·. l'ediat., 6, 397.
10. Chantler, C. and .\\cEnen·, G. (1971): Proc ra\". Sac..\\cd., 6-t, 20.
11. Anand,]. K. and Butler, L.]. (1973): Develap. Med. Child Neurol., 15, 69.
12. Pape, K. E. and Pickering, D. (1972):]. Pediat., 81, 21.
13. Kendall, H..\1. (1972): CenL Afr.] ..\\cd., 18, 162.
14. "elsan, K. B. and Eng, G. D. 19721:]. Pediat., 81,16.
15. flerlman, .\\. and Rei'ner, S. H. 1973): .-\rch. Di>. Childh., 48. 627.
16. Papadaros, D. A., Alexiau, D., "icalapaulos, A. D. ,'I ,iI. 19741: i~i'[ .. -t9,927.
17. Knight, L. and Ed\\'ard>,]. E. (1974): Circulation, 50, lo·n.
18..-\Iexiou, D...\Ianolidis, C, Papae\'angellou, G. ,'I ,iI. 19761: Arch. Di,.
Childh., 51, 91.
19. Hepner, \X·. R. (1951): Pediatric" 8, 494.
20..\1cHugh, H. E., So\\'den, K. A. and Le\'in, .\\. N. (1969): Arch. Orolarmg.,
89, 131.
21. .\lonreal, F. J. (1980): Pediatric>, 65, 1-t6.
22. German. J. L., Rankin, J. K., Harrison, P..-\. ,'I ,iI. (1962): j. PediaL, 60, 103.
23. Lew'i" A. j. (1964): I~i'[ .. 65, 92.
24. Polani, P. E. (1967): GU\"s Hosp. Rep., 116,361.
25..\Iandal, B. '\. (1971): J. [ri,h med ..-\;s., 64, 17.
26. Smith, D. \X'., Patau, K., Therman, E. ,'I </1. (19621: J. PediaL, 60, 113.
27..\\iller, .\\. and Hall,]. G. (19791: .-\mer. j. Di,. Child .. 133.743.